DirectFi
Buying a home

Fixed vs. Adjustable-Rate Mortgages: Which Is Right for You?

Compare fixed-rate and adjustable-rate mortgages: how ARMs adjust, what rate caps do, the risks involved, and when each type tends to make the most sense.

By the DirectFi teamUpdated Oct 5, 20266 min read

Key takeaways

  • A fixed-rate mortgage keeps the same interest rate and principal-and-interest payment for the entire loan term.
  • An ARM starts with a fixed period, often 5, 7 or 10 years, then adjusts periodically based on an index plus a margin.
  • Rate caps limit how much an ARM can change, but your payment can still rise significantly.
  • ARMs tend to fit buyers who expect to move or refinance before the fixed period ends; fixed rates fit long-term owners who value stability.

What is a fixed-rate mortgage?

With a fixed-rate mortgage, your interest rate is set when you lock and never changes. That means your monthly principal and interest payment stays the same from the first payment to the last, whether you choose a 30-year, 20-year or 15-year term.

Your total monthly payment can still change if property taxes or homeowners insurance go up, since those are often collected through escrow. But the loan portion itself is locked in.

How does an adjustable-rate mortgage work?

An adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) has two phases. First comes an initial fixed period, during which the rate doesn't move. After that, the rate resets on a regular schedule for the rest of the loan.

ARMs are named for these two phases. A traditional 5/1 ARM is fixed for five years and then adjusts once a year. Today many ARMs are structured as 5/6 or 7/6, meaning fixed for five or seven years, then adjusting every six months.

When an ARM adjusts, the new rate is generally calculated as:

  • Index: a benchmark interest rate that moves with the market. Many newer ARMs use the Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR).
  • Margin: a fixed number of percentage points the lender adds to the index. The margin is set in your loan documents and doesn't change.

So if the index rises, your rate likely rises at the next adjustment. If the index falls, your rate may fall, subject to the loan's terms.

What are ARM rate caps?

Caps limit how far your rate can move. They're usually written as three numbers, such as 2/1/5 or 5/1/5, though structures vary by loan:

  1. Initial adjustment cap: the most the rate can change at the first reset.
  2. Periodic cap: the most it can change at each later reset.
  3. Lifetime cap: the most it can rise above the starting rate over the life of the loan.

Fixed vs. adjustable: how do they compare?

FeatureFixed-rateAdjustable-rate (ARM)
Interest rateSame for the life of the loanFixed at first, then adjusts on a schedule
Starting rateOften higher than an ARM's intro rateOften lower during the fixed period
Payment predictabilityHighPredictable early, uncertain later
Risk if rates riseNone on the loan ratePayment can increase, within caps
Benefit if rates fallRequires a refinanceRate may fall at adjustment
Often suitsLong-term owners, tight budgetsShorter stays, planned refinances

Note that the gap between ARM and fixed rates isn't constant. In some markets the intro discount on an ARM is meaningful; in others it's small enough that the extra risk isn't worth it. It's worth comparing both side by side when you check today's rates.

When does a fixed-rate mortgage make sense?

  • You plan to stay in the home for many years.
  • Your budget doesn't have much room for a higher payment later.
  • You value peace of mind over a potentially lower starting rate.
  • Rates are relatively low compared with recent history, and you want to keep that rate.

When might an ARM be a better fit?

  • You're fairly confident you'll sell before the fixed period ends, such as with a planned job relocation.
  • You expect your income to rise and can absorb a higher payment later.
  • The ARM's intro rate is meaningfully lower than fixed rates, and you'd put the savings to good use.
  • You're buying a larger home and the lower initial payment helps you qualify, while understanding the risk.

A common plan is to take an ARM and refinance to a fixed rate before the first adjustment. That can work, but it isn't guaranteed. Rates may be higher by then, your home's value could drop, or your finances could change in a way that makes qualifying harder. Build your decision around a scenario where refinancing isn't possible.

What about 15-year vs. 30-year fixed loans?

Within fixed-rate loans, the term matters too. A 15-year loan usually carries a lower rate and costs far less in total interest, but the monthly payment is noticeably higher because you're repaying the balance in half the time. A 30-year loan keeps payments lower and more flexible, and you can generally make extra principal payments if you want to pay it off faster. Check that your loan has no prepayment penalty if that's your plan.

How do I decide between fixed and adjustable?

Start with how long you expect to keep the loan, then look at the worst-case ARM payment and decide honestly whether you could handle it. Compare the actual rate difference, not a general rule. And consider how other choices, like buying mortgage points, change the math.

As a licensed mortgage broker, DirectFi can compare fixed and adjustable options from multiple lenders side by side so you can see the real trade-offs for your situation. When you're ready, start your pre-approval.

Frequently asked questions

What does 5/6 ARM mean?

A 5/6 ARM has a fixed rate for the first five years. After that, the rate adjusts every six months based on its index plus margin, subject to the loan's rate caps.

Can an ARM rate go down?

Yes. If the index falls, your rate may decrease at the next adjustment. However, many ARMs have a floor, often tied to the margin, below which the rate can't fall. Check your loan terms.

Is an ARM riskier than a fixed-rate mortgage?

Generally yes, because your payment can rise after the fixed period. Rate caps limit the increase, but the payment at the maximum rate can still be much higher. Review the worst-case payment before committing.

Can I refinance an ARM into a fixed-rate loan?

Usually, if you qualify at the time. Approval depends on your credit, income and home equity, and the fixed rates available then may be higher or lower than when you bought.

This guide is for general educational purposes and isn't financial, legal, or tax advice. Loan programs, requirements, and rates vary by lender and change over time. DirectFi · NMLS #2375018 · Equal Housing Opportunity.

Keep reading

Talk to a real expert.

DirectFi compares options from multiple lenders so you don't have to.

Get pre-approved today